News.com Mobile
for PDA or phone
Login: Forgot password? | Sign up

Police blotter: Nude 'profile' yields Yahoo suit

By Declan McCullagh
Staff Writer, CNET News.com
Published: December 9, 2005, 9:12 AM PST
Tell us what you think about this storyTalkBack E-mail this story to a friendE-mail View this story formatted for printingPrint See links from elsewhere to this story (TrackBacks/Pingbacks)TrackBack

What: Cecilia Barnes sued Yahoo after ex-boyfriend allegedly posted a personal profile with nude photos of Barnes and her work contact information.

When: U.S. District Judge Ann Aiken in Oregon ruled on Nov. 8.

Outcome: Case dismissed.

What happened: To hear Barnes tell the story, her former boyfriend tried to harass her by creating a series of online profiles with nude photographs of her and her correct contact information at work.

The boyfriend, identified in local news reports as Randolph Russell, allegedly also entered chat rooms posing as Barnes and solicited other men to look at "her" profile. Barnes said those actions led to unwelcome suitors showing up at her workplace.

Barnes says she complained to Yahoo starting in January 2005--and obtained a verbal commitment from a Yahoo employee to help out--but the profiles were not deleted until the lawsuit was filed. Her lawsuit asked for $3 million in damages.

Yahoo argued that a federal law, part of the 1996 Telecommunications Act, means that it's not liable for what other people post on its Web site.

Also called Sec. 230, that law says, "No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider."

Aiken agreed. The judge ruled that a string of precedents, including the 1997 Zeran v. America Online decision, immunized Yahoo from such lawsuits.

Barnes still has other options. Even though she lost out on a $3 million jackpot, she could still sue her ex-boyfriend for damages in state court.

Excerpt from court opinion: "Plaintiff's allegations similarly fall under the broad immunity provided Internet servers by Sec. 230. Plaintiff alleges she was harmed by third-party content and that the service provider (Yahoo) allegedly breached a common law or statutory duty to block, screen, remove, or otherwise edit that content. Any such claim by plaintiff necessarily treats the service provider as 'publisher' of the content and is therefore barred by Sec. 230.

"Plaintiff's argument that she seeks to hold defendant liable only for its alleged 'failure to fulfill its promise to remove the unauthorized profiles' does not remove this case from the immunity provided by Sec. 230. Plaintiff's claim remains an effort to hold the service provider liable for failing to perform the duties of a publisher, such as screening or removing third-party content."

 7 comments
Post a comment

TalkBack

Boy's bathroom

Richard Simpson ii   Dec 10, 2005, 8:13 AM PST

just get the password

Alexis Gonzalez-arguinzoni   Dec 9, 2005, 3:38 PM PST

One time

Nicolas Martin   Dec 9, 2005, 11:09 AM PST

 Read more comments >

Did you know?

Select a tab below to set your default view.

Scan the 15 newest and most read stories on News.com right now. Learn more

Updated: 11:12 PM PST
View as:
A camera that has it all? Well, almost A little sleuthing unmasks writer of Wikipedia prank Prize in Indian talent search: A year on Bill Gates' team Sprint to offer full-length movie downloads Garages hold mythic power in Silicon Valley China overtakes U.S. as supplier of IT goods Intel calls MIT's $100 laptop a 'gadget' Sober code cracked Scientific quests: Better bananas, nicer mosquitoes Creative wants to make Apple pay Power could cost more than servers, Google warns A TV star is born on the Net on $20 a day Philips bringing cell phone TV to states Upstart aims to bring HD camcorders to the masses AOL co-founder calls for split of Time Warner
Legend:
Older
Newer
Larger boxes indicate hotter stories.

Daily spotlight

Video: A video slam-dunk

Here's a look at the tech behind those TV and online highlights of pro basketball games, in a narrated video produced by the NBA and Silicon Graphics Inc.

Photos: Gizmos made in Japan

Japan is still a leader in product design and innovation. Here are some new and notable gadgets.

Video: "The power to organize" online

Meetup.com founder and CEO Scott Heiferman says Meetup is spreading beyond America. The service, Heiferman says, is helping "make the world a friendlier place."

Innovations battle natural calamities

Scientists hope integrating cutting-edge technology projects will help predict and mitigate natural disasters.

Debating Wikipedia's open-source label

High Impact The online encyclopedia is a broadly communal effort, but it's not run the same way as open-source software.

Police blotter: Nude 'profile' yields Yahoo suit

Woman says ex-boyfriend posted nude photos and her phone number in a Yahoo Personals profile. She sued for $3 million.

High-tech animation in indies' grasp

Competing with digital toon powerhouses like Pixar isn't easy. But cheaper tech, outsourcing are making it possible.

Ogre to slay? Outsource it to China

Affluent online gamers are paying workers at Chinese game-playing factories to play games' early rounds for them.

Video: The incredible, shrinking glaciers

This NASA-produced video is a dramatic and colorful look at our planet from high above, and the changes that are taking place.

Image: AOL searches for the stars

TMZ.com, AOL's new online magazine promises inside scoops on Hollywood's hottest stars.

Clock's ticking on new Sober onslaught

Mass-mailing worm is programmed to download new instructions in January, which could indicate a new outbreak.

Photos: New animal discovered in Borneo

A creature that looks like a cross between a cat and a fox is photographed in the rainforest.

CNET.com
Copyright ©2005 CNET Networks, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | About CNET Networks | Jobs | Terms of Use