latest changes & additions at abelard.org link to document abstracts link to list of useful data tables quotations at abelard.org, with source document where relevant      latest news headlines at abelard's news and comment zone Children and television violence interesting site links at abelard's news and comment zone about abelard and abelard.org
visit abelard's gallerylink to short briefings documents economics and money zone at abelard.org - government swindles and how to transfer money on the net   Energy - beyond fossil fuels France zone at abelard.org - another France technology zone at abelard.org: how to survive and thrive on the web  



 

Antarctica melting ice, sea levels, water and weather implications

a briefing document

back to abelard's front page

site map

Google
 
Web abelard.org
 
 
click to see all the indexAntarctica melting ice, sea levels, water and weather implications is one of a series of briefing documents on the problems of power consumption, posed by the steady depletion of fossil fuels and most particularly of pumpable oil.
One of a grouping of documents on global concerns at abelard.org.
On energy
1 Replacing fossil fuels—the scale of the problem
2 Nuclear power - is nuclear power really really dangerous?
3 Replacements for fossil fuels—what can be done about it?
3a Biofuels   3b Photovoltaics (solar cells)
3c tar sands and shale oil
5 Energy economics—how long do we have?
6 Ionising radiation and health—risk analysis
7
Transportable fuels    7a Fuel cells
8 Distributed energy systems and micro-generation
9 Fossil fuel disasters
10 books on energy replacements with reviews

On global warming
4 Global warming
4a Anthropogenic global warming, and ocean acidity
4b energy pricing and greenwash
4c How atmospheric chemistry and physics effects global warming
4d Antarctica melting ice, sea levels, water and weather implications
4e Gathering data to test global warming

Tectonics: tectonic plates - floating on the surface of a cauldron

sustainable futures briefing documents

click to see all the indexIndex
large antarctic melt in 2005
the melting of glaciers
interesting ‘facts’ about antarctica
past ice ages and interglacials
related material
glossary

 

socialize logo To social bookmark this page, click on this link,
then click on your preferred service/s in the list.
More about social bookmarking



advertising
disclaimer

 

 

 

 

 


advertising
disclaimer

 

 

 

 

 


advertising
disclaimer

large antarctic melt in 2005

Antarctica, satellite photo from 2005, marked 
        to show location of Larsen ice shelf Image credit: NASA/JPL.
Antarctica, satellite photo from 2005, with various data added. Original image credit: NASA/JPL
65°S is the equivalent distance from the South Pole as Iceland is from the North Pole.

Recommended, clear article.

“A team of NASA and university scientists has found clear evidence that extensive areas of snow melted in west Antarctica in January 2005 in response to warm temperatures. This was the first widespread Antarctic melting ever detected with NASA's QuikScat satellite and the most significant melt observed using satellites during the past three decades. Combined, the affected regions encompassed an area as big as California.

“The observed melting occurred in multiple distinct regions, including far inland, at high latitudes and at high elevations, where melt had been considered unlikely [...]”

“Antarctica has shown little to no warming in the recent past with the exception of the Antarctic Peninsula [...]

[Note that the part of the peninsular (Larsen Shelf) which suffered large shelf losses in recent decades is further north than the rest of Antarctica.]

“Changes in the ice mass of Antarctica, Earth's largest freshwater reservoir, are important to understanding global sea level rise. Large amounts of Antarctic freshwater flowing into the ocean also could affect ocean salinity, currents and global climate.”

continent / country area in square kilometres
Antartica 14,000,000
Russia 17,075,200
Canada 9,984,670
USA 9,826,630
China 9,596,960
Brazil 8,511,965
Australia 7,686,850


the melting of glaciers

diagram showing glacial ice evolution - melting and slipping away from the bedrock
interactive image: hover with your mouse, clickable areas change to a hand icon
diagram showing glacial ice evolution - melting and slipping away from the bedrock.

  • The ablation zone is where there is an overall loss of glacial material, as the amount of ice melting in Spring and Summer exceeds the amount of Winter snow deposits. The accumulation zone is where snow fall exceeds melting. A balance zone is deemed between these two.

    Although presently, there is a widespread recession of glaciers, be aware that a glacier is a dynamic system that may be advancing one year, and receeding another. Thus, the position of these zones will alter.

  • A warmer planet is expected to be a dustier planet. Vast quantities of dust from erosion and desertification are already being shifted around the planet. If this dust lands on the ice fields, it will reduce albedo. Of course, as the ice fields shrink, the albedo of the earth steadily reduces, adding yet another positive feedback

  • As the ice tongue (the leading edge of the glacier, on the above diagram protruding into the sea) erodes, it has a partial effect of taking a stopper out of a bottle. This allows the glacier to flow more freely. The faster the glacier flows, the more friction heats up the underside of the glacier. As it becomes liquid, that liquid lubricates the glacier, allowing it to flow still more quickly.

  • A glacier thinning results in lower downward pressure. Downward pressure can have two effects, depending upon the conditions:
    • helping to anchor the glacier to the rock substrate;
    • causing heating, and thus melting.

  • Glacier thinning lowers the elevation of ice, and lower elevations are warmer.
    The pressure of large masses of ice also depresses land elevation slightly, so there is some bounce-back as the ice fields melt.

  • On mountain glaciers, a common phenomenon is the undercutting of the rock walls at the sides of the glacier. This causes rock to fall onto the ice, and carves out the great U-valleys that someone probably taught you about in school. These rock falls also change the albedo of the ice surface.

 

interesting ‘facts’ about Antarctica

You will note, by the large ranges of some of these numbers reported by varying sources, that a lot of this is rather optimistic guesswork.

  • Only five percent of the Antarctica coastline is ice-free.

  • Probably fewer than a hundred thousand people have ever visited Antarctica.

  • Antarctica has thirty million cubic kilometres of ice. If this ice melted, the global sea level would rise by an estimated 56 to 80 metres. The Greenland ice sheet is estimated to be capable of rising sea levels by 6 to 7 metres. These ice sheets are estimated to contain about 70 to 90% of the world’s fresh water, 10% of that being in the Greenland ice sheet.

    70% of the Earth’s surface is covered with water. In total, there is about 1½ billion cubic metres of water on the Earth. 97% of that water is sea water (so only 3% is fresh water).

    Satellite measurements of changes in sea levels are presently of the orders of small numbers of millimetres. Measuring and standardising such small differences is very difficult and must be treated with caution.The depth of the seas varies from place to place on the planet by virtue of gravity variations, thermal expansion, changing tides and the land rising and sinking (including that under the sea). Meanwhile, the height of the satellite must be measured against this varying background!

  • The Antarctic forms a huge heat sink, effecting much of the world’s weather systems.

  • The land area of Antarctica is about fifty-eight times that of the British Isles.

  • Greenland and the west Antarctic ice sheets are widely grounded below sea level. As the ice sheets thin, the lowered weight decreases their grip on the land. As the ice shelves recede, the warming water can erode the ice sheet into an ice shelf, and thus the process advances.

  • Several processes are combining in positive feedbacks to increase the rate of melting of the ice sheets and glaciers.

  • Due to the high albedo of the ice sheets, they act as air-conditioning for the planet, as well as there being many communities that are dependent on glaciation to maintain a flow of fresh water during the summer season. There is widespread recession of the majority of glaciers around the world.

 

the melting of glaciers

As already stated, glaciers in general are presently in retreat. It is important to realise that the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets also produce glaciers, some of them very large.

A glacier is not static, it is a moving river of ice. The speed of that river varies according to several conditions. The illustration below gives a summary of the more important of these conditions. Detailed glaciology is a fairly new science, which is receiving considerable attention due to its great importance. This attention includes a lot of effort trying to understand exactly how the flow of ice works. It is not as easy as it sounds, because exploring deep within ice packs varies from dangerous to impossible.

Thus it is that various instrumentation is under continuous development, from dropping camera probes deep into ice fissures, driving for deep core samples and pinging the ice sheets from satellites, together with much else.

 

past ice ages and interglacials

You will find graphs and commentary on recent temperature patterns at medieval warming. I now intend to look at the longer term paleoclimate temperature estimates.

Ice age temperature comparisons. Image credit: globalwarmingart.com

It is useful to remind yourself that temperatures were probably higher for longer in the last interglacial (the Eemian), and that the ice sheets retired further than they have at present. This had the consequence that the seas were higher. But it does look as if we are well on the way to rather accidentally breaking those records.

Notice that in the recent pattern of ice ages, the temperature rises rather rapidly and then starts to steadily peter out. A similar pattern is suggested for the present interglacial as shown in the first of the two graphs linked at medieval warming. In the second graph at medieval warming, can be seen strong hints that this decline pattern has been reversed in the last two hundred years. Of course, the lines do tend to wiggle around according our estimates, but the trends are certainly suggestive, at least to me. You will also notice, from the table below, that the interglacials have not tended to last for a great percentage of the time during the ‘modern’ period.

Steve McIntyre has done something interesting with the first graph in the “ice age temperature changes” diagram, just above. What he has done is to put an arbitrary line across the graph that roughly estimates the planetary temperature at which Toronto becomes free of ice (he lives in Toronto!). And from this arbitrary line, he estimates the approximate lengths of the interglacials.

Steve McIntre's ice age graph.

Start (kyr) End (kyr) Length(kyr)
Holocene 12.3   12.3+
Eemian 130 114 16
240 kyr 244 240 4
330 kyr 337 325 12
Stage 11 418 395 23
[kyr = 1,000 years]

What is important to concentrate on is the completely arbitrary nature of the blue line. Had the line instead been linked to Glasgow or even Ottawa, the interglacials would become shorter; or had the line been moved southwards, the interglacials would, of course, become longer.

The definition of an interglacial is a rather arbitrary moving feast, nor does the glaciation extend tidily to a given latitude. It varies according to land and sea conditions, prevailing winds, and even interactions between the heights of the ice sheets. To add to this, the ice sheets advance and retreat according to their mood.

As you can see from the next diagram:

5 million year temperature comparison. Image credit: globalwarmingart.com

Back beyond the last four hundred thousand years [400kyr], you will see that Toronto would not have had an interglacial for the previous 2.7 million years; whereas going even further back, there would have been no serious glacials for Toronto at all.

65 million year temperature comparison. Image credit: globalwarmingart.com
See The geological timeline for further information on Pal (Palocene), Eo (Eocene) etc.
Recall that on these timescales, planetary climate is also affected by tectonic plate movement.

Thus you will see that this period of glaciation is almost in the nature of a little local difficulty during the history of man, or even of dinosaurs, and I remind you again that here we are talking about Toronto.

Of course, we now have six billion people and growing fast, which we hope to feed. There is also a long-term trend of people moving to the coasts to live and to build vast cities. So interesting as this history is, it won’t be a great comfort if the seas rise by substantial numbers of metres, weather patterns undermine food production and major rivers dry up as glaciers disappear. For example, the Ganges is estimated to be 70% glacial flow during the summer.

“Over 2 million people in the La Paz region depend heavily on the thawing of Chacaltaya and neighboring glaciers for tap water and, indirectly, for electricity supplies.

“ "At least 35 percent of the drinking water comes from melting glaciers, and about 40 percent of the electricity," said Oscar Paz, the head of the Bolivian Climate Change Panel, a government task force.”

“Ecuador's capital Quito, with 1.5 million people, and the Peruvian capital Lima, with 8 million people, also rely on melting glaciers for water and energy supplies.” [Quoted from planetark.org]

related material
pressure on water resources
giant ice shelf broke free in the arctic

glossary

ice shelf:
floats on the sea/ocean;
ice sheet:
situated on land.
Thus, an ice shelf is effected by water temperature. The water is quite often frozen right down to the ocean floor. Thus the ice may not be acting as a shelf, but still be in contact with the water at the ice face. Shelved ice is under greater stress and, therefore, can be subject to major break-up.

click to return to the index

Related further documents
On energy
1 Replacing fossil fuels—the scale of the problem
2 Nuclear power - is nuclear power really really dangerous?
3 Replacements for fossil fuels—what can be done about it?
3a Biofuels   3b Photovoltaics (solar cells)
3c tar sands and shale oil
5 Energy economics—how long do we have?
6 Ionising radiation and health—risk analysis
7
Transportable fuels    7a Fuel cells
8 Distributed energy systems and micro-generation
9 Fossil fuel disasters
10 books on energy replacements with reviews

On global warming
4 Global warming
4a Anthropogenic global warming, and ocean acidity
4b energy pricing and greenwash
4c How atmospheric chemistry and physics effects global warming
4d Antarctica melting ice, sea levels, water and weather implications
4e Gathering data to test global warming

Tectonics: tectonic plates - floating on the surface of a cauldron

sustainable futures briefing documents


return to abelard.org main site news and comment at abelard.org documents on alternative energies documents on alternative energies Japan zone sum will set you free art gallery the web pilot - mastering the Internet short briefings documents on energy and society Link to abelard.org's RSS newsfeed

email abelard email abelard at abelard.org

© abelard, 2007,17 may

all rights reserved

the address for this document is http://www.abelard.org/briefings/antarctica_melting_ice.php

2500 words
prints as 7 A4 pages (on my printer and set-up)

latest abstracts briefings information   headlines resources interesting about abelard