Chessville
...by Chessplayers, for Chessplayers!
Today is


Site Map

If you have disabled Java for your browser, use the Site Map (linked in the header and footer).

Chessville
logo by
ChessPrints


Advertise
with
Chessville!!

Advertise to
thousands
of chess
fans for
as little
as
$25.

Single insert:
$35
x4 insert:
@ $25 each.



From the
Chessville
Chess Store



 


 


From the
Chessville
Chess Store

 

 

 

 

 

CENSORED!
Botvinnik's Secret Games

by Jan Timman

Reviewed by NM Bill McGeary

Hardinge Simpole Publishing, 2006

ISBN: 1843821788

softcover, 194 pages

Greek mythology is full of powerful gods, their exploits and hidden affairs.  So it is also with world champions atop the chess Olympus.  Taking the crown of chess brings the focus of the chess public directly on the champion.  Botvinnik was no exception.

Being probably the first truly modern world champion, Botvinnik's method of training and preparation were both mysterious and the matter of much speculation.  I grew up in the age of the Informants, and scurrying around to find newspaper columns with games or any scrap of international news was as much a part of chess as carrying a set.  In those days we all reveled at the work of the Soviets, with Botvinnik being the greatest example of preparation of them all.  We had access to his games, of course, but as to the work he did behind the scenes we had only rumor.  Generations have come and gone with that speculation.

Now, as if one of the gods from Olympus has descended, a book appears with much information about Botvinnik's preparation.  CENSORED!  Botvinnik's Secret Games contains the scores of 97 of Botvinnik's training games.  The author states that three of the games had been previously published, but otherwise these are all new to the chess playing world.

Trying to compare this to the discovery of lost artifacts in other fields is very difficult because of the nature of the games and the time span they carry.  The first games were played in 1936 for a Soviet Championship and the final games for the 1970 USSR vs. the World match.  Spanning three generations, these games represent an entire change in the approach to chess by professionals, perhaps even determining the necessary efforts to be a professional chess player.

The intriguing thing in all of this is the nature of the scores.  Timman makes reference in the book to games that Botvinnik believes were communicated to his adversaries.  Since it was likely one of the conditions of playing that the score remain a secret it becomes a question of where the scores had been kept?  Perhaps Botvinnik's personal records contained them as he was not a man to release information lightly.  Or perhaps there was some Soviet archive?

The three games previously published were against Averbakh, a highly placed official in the Soviet system who would hardly fear any backlash from Botvinnik.  In any case, after nearly 40 years we have access to the scores and the rumors that had been such a part of the chess drama have been proven correct.

The games themselves are of an uneven quality.  Some of the games were adjourned and never finished.  Commentaries by Averbakh explain that Botvinnik wanted to play in "tournament like" conditions and would have the radio on in the background for the entire game, simulating spectator noise.

A fair number of the games are annotated by Timman, whose notes are always worthy of attention.  The really fascinating part is the commentary about the situations that games were played in.  We see Botvinnik playing 1.e4  and the Black side of the Benoni and Kings Indian in preparation for Tal, spawning novelties in the Slav for a return match with Smyslov, and games in that defense most associated with Botvinnik's name, the French.  This is truly an amazing bit of chess history that has come to light.

I suspect that the largest percentage of today's chessplayers know Botvinnik only in name and do not fathom the enormity of the effect that Botvinnik  has had on the chess world.  To players later in age we know many names and many tales, but none carries the importance of Botvinnik.  Perhaps in 60 years we will be treated to some mysterious lost archive of Kasparov's work.

From the Publisher's Website:

Botvinnik’s training games were a well guarded secret only shared by a few trusty colleagues, such as the Grandmasters Ragozin, Averbakh and Furman. The Soviet state was a monument to paranoia at the best of times, but suspicion multiplied when world titles hinged on secrecy, and these games have lain hidden for decades after they were played. Botvinnik was World Champion three times, from 1948-1957, 1958 -1960 and 1961 -1963. His final championship victory against Tal in the 1961 revenge match counts as one of the highest scoring rating performances in the history of chess. It was of course based on the most meticulous preparation, not least in the psychological sphere of seeking to find and play positions which were not to Tal’s taste.
 

Grandmaster Jan Timman is one of the most popular and colourful players on the modern scene. A finalist in the FIDE-World Chess Federation-World Chess Championship in 1993, Timman has been the second dominating force in Dutch chess after world champion Dr Max Euwe. Here Timman presents every Botvinnik training game which could be found and subjects the most important to typically close analytical and explanatory scrutiny.
 

Index
of all
Reviews


Chess Books
& Equipment

 

search tips

The
Chessville
Chess Store



Chess
Play free online chess
 

A Chess Book a Mortal can enjoy?

Like Learning a Face-Stomping Opening
over Beer and Onion Rings!

"...perfect opening for non-masters
...many brutal muggings
"
- IM Silman

(Reviews,
Excerpts and Comments Here.)



Reference
Center


The Chessville
 Weekly
The Best Free

Chess
Newsletter
On the Planet!

Subscribe
Today -

It's Free!!

The
Chessville
Weekly
Archives


Discussion
Forum


Chess Links


Chess Rules


Visit the
Chessville
Chess Store

 

 

This site is best viewed with Java-Enabled MS Internet Explorer 6 and Netscape 6 browsers set at 800x600 screen size.

Copyright 2002-2008 Chessville.com unless otherwise noted.